Tiling to gypsum based substrates/backgrounds. - Tile Advice

[Dave]

Just thought I would see who is using gypsum adhesives when tiling to gypsum substrates/backgrounds .

you might be using say anhydrocol or Anhyfix or GBTA etc on say an anhydrite screed but are you now using them on skimmed gypsum walls.?

Are you still using cement based adhesives for tiling to skimmed walls but using gypsum adhesive on floors , if so why ? .

look forward to who uses what and if so why.

 

[Stef]

I always use a gypsum addy to a gypsum screed, AnhyFix always, it just sits better in my head knowing the 2 are compatible.
I have used AnhyFix to walls if I've adhesive left over & needed used.
I know what your getting at Dave, maybe I don't bother as much on plaster walls because they are not heated..

 

[Dave]

If a floor wasn't heated Stef , would you use cement based adhesive ? Or stick to gypsum adhesive.

if you feel safer tiling to gypsum floors with gypsum adhesive , would you feel safer using same to skimmed walls ? , after all the same reaction occurs when using cement based adhesives, be it wall or floor.

 

[Sean SML Tiling]

What do you do dave? I personally hate using fast set these days. So for me anhyfix on anhydrite screed and cement on plaster. You have a great point tho

 

[peteablard]

After a lengthy discussion with the builder on my first anhydrite floor I ended up using Weber SPF and primed with PR360. He insisted I went down this route rather than a gypsum based adhesive. Had no problems and have used the same ever since. Done 6 or 7 now heated and unheated with no problems. Always moisture tested, commissioned and prepped properly I can't see why there would be any issues.

 

[Dave]

What do you do dave? I personally hate using fast set these days. So for me anhyfix on anhydrite screed and cement on plaster. You have a great point tho

i have always used cement based but so far all screeds have been heated , I have one to do very soon and its unheated
, so I'm going to use Anhyfix as it allows that extra % of moisture in the screed , just incase lol...

walls ? , well as usual I use cement based..

 

[Stef]

If a floor wasn't heated Stef , would you use cement based adhesive ? Or stick to gypsum adhesive.

if you feel safer tiling to gypsum floors with gypsum adhesive , would you feel safer using same to skimmed walls ? , after all the same reaction occurs when using cement based adhesives, be it wall or floor.

If the floor wasn't heated I would still use AnhyFix Dave. It just sits better in my head & I've had a few discussions with myself on this subject.
I know the same reactions occur be it wall or floors & your relying on your primer creating that barrier between the addy & substrate.
It sounds daft when you look at it as you say the substrates are the same & the same reactions occur.

 

[Dave]

After a lengthy discussion with the builder on my first anhydrite floor I ended up using Weber SPF and primed with PR360. He insisted I went down this route rather than a gypsum based adhesive. Had no problems and have used the same ever since. Done 6 or 7 now heated and unheated with no problems. Always moisture tested, commissioned and prepped properly I can't see why there would be any issues.

I have a builder I have worked for around 18 yrs and he's the same , I have tiled loads of anhydrite with cement based and ALL have been ok , so he sees no reason to change to such a relatively new product when what we use works fine .


my opinion is , we are being scare mongered into using new products and stating nothing else will suffice , when that isn't true.. Lol..

 

[Stef]

i have always used cement based but so far all screeds have been heated , I have one to do very soon and its unheated
, so I'm going to use Anhyfix as it allows that extra % of moisture in the screed , just incase lol...

walls ? , well as usual I use cement based..

AnhyFix let's you tile at 85% RH but I still wait till my meter reads 75% or below.

Here's one for you Dave, I've a floor coming up & will more than likely have to slc certain bits as the screed is not great.
Would you prime & use a cement based slc to save some money?

 

[Dave]

If the floor wasn't heated I would still use AnhyFix Dave. It just sits better in my head & I've had a few discussions with myself on this subject.
I know the same reactions occur be it wall or floors & your relying on your primer creating that barrier between the addy & substrate.
It sounds daft when you look at it as you say the substrates are the same & the same reactions occur.

im in the mindset , that if you prep each job correctly be it walls to floor , then cement based works but if we start to,use gypsum addy , then really we should be using it on both wall and floors ...

 

[Dave]

AnhyFix let's you tile at 85% RH but I still wait till my meter reads 75% or below.

Here's one for you Dave, I've a floor coming up & will more than likely have to slc certain bits as the screed is not great.
Would you prime & use a cement based slc to save some money?

Is this a gypsum screed stef ? If so , then I've not levelled one before , but I do know there are gypsum levellers now lol.. But as you say , if the screed is dry and primed correctly , then yes Imho a cement based slc would be fine.. But do we take the risk is another question ?

 

[Sean SML Tiling]

i have always used cement based but so far all screeds have been heated , I have one to do very soon and its unheated
, so I'm going to use Anhyfix as it allows that extra % of moisture in the screed , just incase lol...

walls ? , well as usual I use cement based..

After all the info on here my first anhydrite I went with anhyfix as the weber rep didn't give me any confidence on what was the correct method.

 

[Stef]

im in the mindset , that if you prep each job correctly be it walls to floor , then cement based works but if we start to,use gypsum addy , then really we should be using it on both wall and floors ...

It's a good marketing ploy though as the gypsum addy is a premium compared to cement based.
I've done one Gyvlon with a cement based addy & it failed but it was tiled in 7 days as the builder wanted clients moved in & his money & floor would get sorted at a later date.
I suppose this has always stuck in my mind even though I know why it failed, I've never had bother tiling to plaster so why should I have bother with a screed!!

 

[Dave]

After all the info on here my first anhydrite I went with anhyfix as the weber rep didn't give me any confidence on what was the correct method.

After past experiences with reps , I would not take a reps advice ever again lol.. Most are new to the game and TBO ain't got a clue.

 

[peteablard]

I have a builder I have worked for around 18 yrs and he's the same , I have tiled loads of anhydrite with cement based and ALL have been ok , so he sees no reason to change to such a relatively new product when what we use works fine .


my opinion is , we are being scare mongered into using new products and stating nothing else will suffice , when that isn't true.. Lol..

Thats pretty much word for word what my builder says. He's not daft and has done a lot of research about the different adhesives and I can't see him every changing from this method. I'm confident doing it this way and the builder always explains to the customer and the plumber about using the UFH the first time. I've got another one to tile for him in a few weeks when it's dry!